Skip to content

Eggnog Recipe: Creamy Christmas Drink, With or Without Rumएगनॉग

A cooked custard of milk, cream, egg yolks and nutmeg, chilled and spiked with brandy or rum. Rich, creamy and very festive.

  • 130 min
  • Medium
  • Tumbler
  • ~7% ABV
  • Zero-proof twin

Classic recipeOur kitchen test pending · how we test

Creamy eggnog with cinnamon and star anise

6¼:1

Whole milk : Dark rum

86%Whole milk14%Dark rum
Jump to recipe

Recipe

Makes
4 drinks

Ingredients

  • 4Egg, yolks only
  • 4 tbspSugar
  • 500 mlWhole milk
  • ½ tspNutmeg, freshly grated
  • 80 ml2¾ pegsDark rum
    Swap
    • Brandy
Tools
Kadhai or heavy pan, Slotted spoon, Thermometer
Ice
None (serve chilled)
Garnish
Freshly grated nutmeg

Method

  1. 01Whisk egg yolks and sugar until pale and thick.
  2. 02Heat the milk until steaming, then pour slowly into the yolks, whisking all the time.
  3. 03Return to the pan and stir on low heat until it coats a spoon. Do not boil. · about 5 min
  4. 04Strain, chill for at least two hours, then stir in the rum and nutmeg. · about 120 min

Why this works

Cooking the yolks gently into a light custard makes eggnog safe and silky without raw egg. Adding the spirit after chilling keeps its flavour bright.

Variations

Brandy eggnog
Use brandy instead of rum for a fruitier, more traditional version.

Batch it for a party

Drinks
16
Pitcher
2.32 L
Top up at service
—
Ice
12 kg
Shopping amounts
IngredientTotal750 ml bottles
Whole milk2 L—
Dark rum320 ml1

Keeps 2 days in the fridge. Stir before serving.

Common mistakes

  1. 1.Pouring hot milk in too fast — the yolks scramble.
  2. 2.Boiling the custard — it splits.

Questions

Is eggnog safe?

This recipe cooks the yolks into a custard, so it does not use raw egg.

Share on WhatsApp

Recipe by

Peg & Pour Test Kitchen

Recipes are developed against published classic specifications, then tested in three rounds by two tasters using a jigger and scale, with dilution recorded. Named bartender profiles will appear here as each recipe is signed off.

Editorial policy · Testing process

Ask Chef — AI recipe for any dish