Skip to content

Coquito Recipe: Puerto Rican Coconut Rum Eggnog

Coconut milk, cream of coconut and condensed milk blended with rum and warm spices. Bottled, chilled and shared at Christmas.

  • 250 min
  • Easy
  • Tumbler
  • ~10% ABV
  • Zero-proof twin

Classic recipeOur kitchen test pending · how we test

Coquito
36%Coconut milk32%Evaporated milk32%White rum0%Vanilla extract
Jump to recipe

Recipe

Makes
20 drinks

Ingredients

  • 400 mlCoconut milk
  • 425 gCream of coconut
  • 397 gCondensed milk
  • 355 mlEvaporated milk
  • 360 ml12 pegsWhite rum
  • 5 mlVanilla extract
  • 1 tspGround cinnamon
Tools
Blender, Jigger
Ice
Cubed ice

Method

  1. 01Warm the coconut tins in warm water so the fat loosens.
  2. 02Blend coconut milk, cream of coconut and spices, then the milks and vanilla.
  3. 03Stir in the rum and bottle with a cinnamon stick.
  4. 04Chill four hours; shake hard before pouring 60 ml servings. · about 240 min

Why this works

Warming the tins melts the coconut fat so it blends smoothly. It thickens in the fridge, so shake before serving.

Batch it for a party

Drinks
16
Pitcher
895 ml
Top up at service
—
Ice
12 kg
Shopping amounts
IngredientTotal750 ml bottles
Coconut milk320 ml—
Evaporated milk285 ml—
White rum290 ml1
Vanilla extract5 ml—
Share on WhatsApp

Recipe by

Peg & Pour Test Kitchen

Recipes are developed against published classic specifications, then tested in three rounds by two tasters using a jigger and scale, with dilution recorded. Named bartender profiles will appear here as each recipe is signed off.

Editorial policy · Testing process

Ask Chef — AI recipe for any dish