Coquito Recipe: Puerto Rican Coconut Rum Eggnog
Coconut milk, cream of coconut and condensed milk blended with rum and warm spices. Bottled, chilled and shared at Christmas.
- 250 min
- Easy
- Tumbler
- ~10% ABV
- Zero-proof twin
Classic recipeOur kitchen test pending · how we test

Recipe
Makes20 drinks
Ingredients
- 400 mlCoconut milk
- 425 gCream of coconut
- 397 gCondensed milk
- 355 mlEvaporated milk
- 360 mlWhite rum
- 5 mlVanilla extract
- 1 tspGround cinnamon
- Tools
- Blender, Jigger
- Ice
- Cubed ice
Method
- 01Warm the coconut tins in warm water so the fat loosens.
- 02Blend coconut milk, cream of coconut and spices, then the milks and vanilla.
- 03Stir in the rum and bottle with a cinnamon stick.
- 04Chill four hours; shake hard before pouring 60 ml servings. · about 240 min
Why this works
Warming the tins melts the coconut fat so it blends smoothly. It thickens in the fridge, so shake before serving.
Batch it for a party
- Drinks
- 16
- Pitcher
- 895 ml
- Top up at service
- —
- Ice
- 12 kg
| Ingredient | Total | 750 ml bottles |
|---|---|---|
| Coconut milk | 320 ml | — |
| Evaporated milk | 285 ml | — |
| White rum | 290 ml | 1 |
| Vanilla extract | 5 ml | — |
Recipe by
Peg & Pour Test Kitchen
Recipes are developed against published classic specifications, then tested in three rounds by two tasters using a jigger and scale, with dilution recorded. Named bartender profiles will appear here as each recipe is signed off.



